The purpose of this article is not to persuade you that long-term partnerships are good. You already know that. It’s about how to do them well.
How should your testing period look, before committing to a long-term partnership?
How do you overcome audience fatigue after months of working with the same creator? What do you do if creatives start to fall flat after a few months?
With the help of some seasoned pros, I’ll answer those questions & more. Let’s go!
Always run a trial period first (here’s how)
Influencer partnerships aren’t ad campaigns. If you engage in a 6-month contract with a creator, you can’t just turn it off if it isn’t working halfway through.
You need to build a process to trial new creators before making a long-term commitment.
How to pitch a trial period to creators
Trial periods are a win-win, and with the right pitch, creators will understand that too.
During his time at FARFETCH, Ben Williams used the potential of a long-term partnership as an incentive during initial conversations.
Now let’s see what these trial periods actually look like in practice.
3 real examples of how brands do trial periods
1. Deeper Sonars
Deeper’s trial period usually lasts three months. They start by sending out a product kit tailored to the creator’s style of fishing, and they ask for one key deliverable each month.
Around 85% of creators continue after their trial with Deeper. The number is high because they do a lot of vetting & analysis up front. After that, here’s Valeriia’s criteria for continuing:
- The creator is competent at using the product (they use the sonar correctly)
- The creator is responsive
- The reach and engagement align with expectations (or exceed them)
- Pricing for further collaborations still align with the budget
2. One Medical
The partnership kicks off with an onboarding call. Once they know what kind of story they want to tell, Georgina works with each creator to decide deliverables case-by-case. Each creator also gets a free one-year One Medical membership. That adds value, and ensures that creators have an authentic experience.
Historically, Georgina has been tracking awareness & new member sign ups (by promo code redemptions). Moving forward, her priority is local awareness of One Medical's Amazon Prime offering. Clicks, engagement, and quality of engagements.
There are multiple deliverables in the initial deal (e.g. 2x Stories & 1 Reel), but no commitment for further activations.
(They almost never experience pushback from creators asking for longer terms – but your experience might vary per market or niche.)
For Aumio, a typical long-term relationship might develop like this:
- First month: one activation
- Second month: another (similar) activation
- If things went well, commit to a longer period (e.g. 3 months)
Even though 60-70% of Aumio’s promo code redemptions come from creators that they’ve collaborated with 5+ times, Anna rarely makes deals that last longer than 3 months. Because:
- They only have one core product, so audience fatigue is a challenge, and
- They want the option to stop, and to navigate seasonality (e.g. sales typically dip in summer)
As ever, there’s no “right” way to do a trial period – these examples are just for inspiration.
Managing creative fatigue
You sign a long-term contract with a new creator. They’re full of energy. Content is great.
Fast-forward 3 months, and their content starts to become stale. There’s less effort, less enthusiasm, and weaker results. It feels like they’re just checking a box to fulfill the contract.
(Note: exhausting the audience is a separate issue. We’ll get to that in a minute. We’re talking specifically about creative fatigue here.)
Here are three ideas to solve the problem.
Invest your time into helpful content feedback
Giving time 1:1 with the creator to brainstorm creatives can be a big unlock.
If you’re successful, the relationship improves, your messaging is delivered better, and the creator is excited & brimming with content ideas.
First thing to remember: the creator might know their audience best, but Rugile Paleviciute (Head of Partnerships, Burga) reminds us that you know your product best. Inputs from both sides are needed.
And if you’ve been working in the social media space for a while, there’s a good chance you have even more to offer too. It’s not just about product knowledge.
Anna Fatlowitz is Director of Influencer Marketing at a food media company, feedfeed. They invest heavily in their own social media presence – which means they know what works in organic social, and their expertise can help creators too.
Anna’s team are hands-on in the collaboration process. They work with creators to approve concepts, suggest opening hooks, and more.
Add incentives outside of flat fees
There isn’t anything wrong with having contracts that are based solely around flat fees – it works for many brands & influencers.
But if you structure deals like that and you have problems with creative fatigue, consider adding another incentive.
Negotiating a performance-based element to the compensation is one possible incentive.
If events aren’t on the table, and you can’t easily track sales via links or codes, you can also try including flat-rate bonuses. For example, an extra $X based on a reach or engagement target.
The core idea is to structure the deal so that the outcome is better for the influencer if they knock it out of the park.
Space out your activations
If you’re still having trouble, consider redefining what a “long-term partnership” means to you.
Not every collaboration has to have a weekly or monthly cadence. Ben Williams suggests leveraging those relationships partly based on seasonality.
Managing audience fatigue
Even if the creator is still engaged, you might still “exhaust” their audience. That’s a separate problem.
After X months of promoting your brand, there’s a good chance the creator’s followers are already aware of your brand by this point. They’ve either bought, or they’re not going to… right?
Typically, the fewer products you offer, the more of a challenge this will be. And sometimes you really should just hit “pause”.
That said, if you want to explore whether you can extend the lifespan of your long-term influencer partnerships, here are some best practices.
1. Reduce the chance of fatigue by working with high growth creators
It’s easier said than done, but the simplest way is to work with creators who are constantly adding new followers.
Ben Williams favors this approach:
By far the easiest way to find fast-growing influencers is to filter with software. In Modash, after you’ve applied your usual criteria (audience demographics, follower range, min. engagement rate etc.) you can filter by follower growth too.
For example, “show me only creators that have grown by at least 50% in the last 6 months”.
And if you’re evaluating an influencer that you found via a different method, and you discover that they’re achieving fast follower growth – consider that in the negotiations. It might make them worth a little more to you.
2. Switch up the creative angle
There’s a lot of overlap between “creative fatigue” & “audience fatigue”.
Audiences don’t get tired of hearing about your brand. They just get tired of hearing the same message over and over.
One thing you can do is to pivot that message. Most influencer campaigns have a main talking point, a specific product line, or an evergreen value prop.
Assuming the influencer has been able to use your product through your collaboration, they can also start sharing unique, authentic experiences about long-term use.
Dmitri also suggests introducing "sneak peeks" into new and upcoming products, which benefits both you & the creator.
3. Boost content to a wider audience via paid ads
If you think you’ve exhausted the organic audience, and the creator isn’t growing fast but you really like their content, consider amplifying their reach with paid ads.
You can do this with any creator, but your long-term partners could be the best candidates.
Keeping track of creator content
I’m not going to go into detail on reporting sales impact from long-term partners. That’s a whole other post.
Right now, we’re talking about the step before that: just keeping track of which creators have even published at all (and what they posted).
As you add more creators, this can get difficult. If long-term partners miss their deliverables, it’s your job to stay on top of it, right?
Shayna Macklin also keeps track of creator deliverables mostly manually. Here’s her tips:
If you don’t have precise posting dates, that gets a little trickier. And when the volume of influencer content grows, it gets even tougher to manage. That’s when using a paid influencer tracking tool becomes more viable.
Valeriia & team Deeper use Modash to collect all the content from long-term ambassadors. They check in once per week, with campaigns divided by country & social platform (e.g. Instagram / Sweden, shown below). Then, they can follow up with anyone who hasn’t posted the expected deliverables.
You give the tool a list of creators, and a way to identify the content (e.g. posts using a certain hashtag or mention). Then all content (even Stories) gets automatically tracked & added to a dashboard.
Tips for juggling lots of long-term relationships
Simply juggling all your relationships is one of the trickiest parts of scaling influencer marketing.
As your brand onboards more influencers, how the heck do you maintain those personal 1:1 relationships?
First up, know that the work involved with each partnership is front-heavy. In the first month or two there’s onboarding, extra back-and-forth with creative, more education, and general getting to know each other.
The longer you work together, the less work you’ll have to put in (usually). This is Josie Hull’s experience of working with long-term partners.
Getting to that point of seamless working with your proven long-term partners is one of the keys to scaling your influencer channel. The less time you need to give to each creator, the more creators you can manage.
If you can, build a team structure that enables focus
At Ruggable, Dmitri Cherner (former Director of Influencer Marketing) separated the teams who look after new vs. existing influencer partnerships.
Finding new partners is a ton of work: vetting, outreach, considering rates, content, engagement. Email back-and-forth. And much more.
As you grow, it’s extremely difficult for a single person to recruit new influencers, and look after your long-term partners at the same time.
What if you don’t have enough people?
I suspect most people reading this don’t have the team size to execute on that ☝ advice.
The fundamental concept still applies: prioritize your long-term partners, and clear headspace to give them the attention they need.
For the 1-person teams, here’s some advice from Shayna Macklin:
And if you have multiple people, but not enough to separate teams, here’s what Anna-Maria Klappenbach suggests:
How to find influencers for long-term partnerships
Running long-term influencer partnerships is difficult, but none of this stuff matters until you’ve found creators in the first place.
Brands that are successful in influencer marketing typically have a mix of tactics to find new partners.
We ran a survey on finding influencers, with inputs from 63 full-time influencer marketing pros. I recommend reading, but here’s the quick version of the top 2 tactics.
Browse directly on social media (the free way)
The most common method is to simply browse directly on social platforms like IG. For example Josie Hull curated her personal social feeds around her target topics.
If you’re just starting, or working with a small volume of creators, that’s where you should start.
Use software (the paid way)
The second most common method, which is faster & provides more data, is to use influencer search tools like Modash. That lets you apply filters (like audience locations, minimum engagement rates, and more) to skip irrelevant creators, and recruit much faster.
You can run a search, then open up a profile to analyze the audience, performance, and content. It looks something like this:
We have a newsletter (woohoo!)
It’s so difficult to find real examples and helpful advice from people that actually do influencer partnerships full-time.
We’re trying to solve that with content like this. And now you can subscribe to it!
The newsletter is called Return on Influence. My content-partner-in-crime, Eleni Zoe, summarizes the 80/20 of topics like this one. The idea is to give actionable influencer marketing advice & examples right in the inbox. With no need to click on anything, read 3k+ word articles, or listen to 1h+ podcasts.
See the past editions here. If that’s up your street, subscribe for free, and follow along with what we’re learning.
Lastly, I’m personally happy to connect with new people on LinkedIn.
Catch you in the next one!